{ "ok": true, "domain": "thebulwark.com", "generated_at": "2026-08-10T21:20:34-05:00", "cache": { "hit": true, "ttl": 0 }, "score": { "total": 83, "label": "Good", "categories": { "dns": 80, "mail": 90, "security": 73, "network": 70, "availability": 100 }, "category_weights": { "dns": 25, "mail": 20, "security": 25, "network": 10, "availability": 20 }, "items": [ { "category": "dns", "title": "IPv4 (A)", "max_points": 30, "earned_points": 30, "lost_points": 0, "detail": "2 IPv4 address(es) detected." }, { "category": "dns", "title": "IPv6 (AAAA)", "max_points": 10, "earned_points": 10, "lost_points": 0, "detail": "2 IPv6 address(es) detected." }, { "category": "dns", "title": "Name server redundancy", "max_points": 20, "earned_points": 20, "lost_points": 0, "detail": "2 NS record(s); 2 or more required." }, { "category": "dns", "title": "SOA record", "max_points": 10, "earned_points": 10, "lost_points": 0, "detail": "Authoritative zone record." }, { "category": "dns", "title": "DNSSEC chain", "max_points": 15, "earned_points": 0, "lost_points": 15, "detail": "Both DS and DNSKEY are required." }, { "category": "dns", "title": "CAA policy", "max_points": 5, "earned_points": 0, "lost_points": 5, "detail": "Certificate authority restriction." }, { "category": "dns", "title": "DNS propagation", "max_points": 10, "earned_points": 10, "lost_points": 0, "detail": "Agreement between public resolvers." }, { "category": "mail", "title": "MX records", "max_points": 20, "earned_points": 20, "lost_points": 0, "detail": "5 MX record(s)." }, { "category": "mail", "title": "SPF", "max_points": 25, "earned_points": 25, "lost_points": 0, "detail": "SPF policy published." }, { "category": "mail", "title": "DMARC", "max_points": 25, "earned_points": 25, "lost_points": 0, "detail": "DMARC policy published." }, { "category": "mail", "title": "DKIM", "max_points": 20, "earned_points": 20, "lost_points": 0, "detail": "A DKIM selector was verified." }, { "category": "mail", "title": "MTA-STS", "max_points": 5, "earned_points": 0, "lost_points": 5, "detail": "Mail transport policy." }, { "category": "mail", "title": "TLS-RPT", "max_points": 5, "earned_points": 0, "lost_points": 5, "detail": "TLS reporting policy." }, { "category": "security", "title": "Valid TLS certificate", "max_points": 55, "earned_points": 55, "lost_points": 0, "detail": "45 day(s) remaining." }, { "category": "security", "title": "Certificate lifetime", "max_points": 10, "earned_points": 10, "lost_points": 0, "detail": "Full points require at least 30 days remaining." }, { "category": "security", "title": "HTTP security headers", "max_points": 35, "earned_points": 8, "lost_points": 27, "detail": "2 of 9 evaluated headers detected." }, { "category": "network", "title": "PTR reverse DNS", "max_points": 30, "earned_points": 0, "lost_points": 30, "detail": "PTR not detected." }, { "category": "network", "title": "IPv4 diversity", "max_points": 35, "earned_points": 35, "lost_points": 0, "detail": "Two or more IPv4 addresses receive full points." }, { "category": "network", "title": "IPv6 connectivity", "max_points": 35, "earned_points": 35, "lost_points": 0, "detail": "AAAA availability." }, { "category": "availability", "title": "DNS resolution", "max_points": 40, "earned_points": 40, "lost_points": 0, "detail": "At least one address family must resolve." }, { "category": "availability", "title": "HTTP response", "max_points": 40, "earned_points": 40, "lost_points": 0, "detail": "HTTP/2 200 " }, { "category": "availability", "title": "HTTPS final URL", "max_points": 20, "earned_points": 20, "lost_points": 0, "detail": "Final URL uses HTTPS." } ], "methodology": "Each category is normalized to 100. The total is the weighted sum: DNS 25%, Email 20%, Security 25%, Network 10%, Availability 20%.", "diagnostics": [ { "level": "ok", "title": "IPv4 (A)", "detail": "2 IPv4 address(es) detected.", "category": "dns", "max_points": 30, "earned_points": 30, "lost_points": 0 }, { "level": "ok", "title": "IPv6 (AAAA)", "detail": "2 IPv6 address(es) detected.", "category": "dns", "max_points": 10, "earned_points": 10, "lost_points": 0 }, { "level": "ok", "title": "Name server redundancy", "detail": "2 NS record(s); 2 or more required.", "category": "dns", "max_points": 20, "earned_points": 20, "lost_points": 0 }, { "level": "ok", "title": "SOA record", "detail": "Authoritative zone record.", "category": "dns", "max_points": 10, "earned_points": 10, "lost_points": 0 }, { "level": "error", "title": "DNSSEC chain", "detail": "Both DS and DNSKEY are required.", "category": "dns", "max_points": 15, "earned_points": 0, "lost_points": 15 }, { "level": "error", "title": "CAA policy", "detail": "Certificate authority restriction.", "category": "dns", "max_points": 5, "earned_points": 0, "lost_points": 5 }, { "level": "ok", "title": "DNS propagation", "detail": "Agreement between public resolvers.", "category": "dns", "max_points": 10, "earned_points": 10, "lost_points": 0 }, { "level": "ok", "title": "MX records", "detail": "5 MX record(s).", "category": "mail", "max_points": 20, "earned_points": 20, "lost_points": 0 }, { "level": "ok", "title": "SPF", "detail": "SPF policy published.", "category": "mail", "max_points": 25, "earned_points": 25, "lost_points": 0 }, { "level": "ok", "title": "DMARC", "detail": "DMARC policy published.", "category": "mail", "max_points": 25, "earned_points": 25, "lost_points": 0 }, { "level": "ok", "title": "DKIM", "detail": "A DKIM selector was verified.", "category": "mail", "max_points": 20, "earned_points": 20, "lost_points": 0 }, { "level": "error", "title": "MTA-STS", "detail": "Mail transport policy.", "category": "mail", "max_points": 5, "earned_points": 0, "lost_points": 5 }, { "level": "error", "title": "TLS-RPT", "detail": "TLS reporting policy.", "category": "mail", "max_points": 5, "earned_points": 0, "lost_points": 5 }, { "level": "ok", "title": "Valid TLS certificate", "detail": "45 day(s) remaining.", "category": "security", "max_points": 55, "earned_points": 55, "lost_points": 0 }, { "level": "ok", "title": "Certificate lifetime", "detail": "Full points require at least 30 days remaining.", "category": "security", "max_points": 10, "earned_points": 10, "lost_points": 0 }, { "level": "warning", "title": "HTTP security headers", "detail": "2 of 9 evaluated headers detected.", "category": "security", "max_points": 35, "earned_points": 8, "lost_points": 27 }, { "level": "error", "title": "PTR reverse DNS", "detail": "PTR not detected.", "category": "network", "max_points": 30, "earned_points": 0, "lost_points": 30 }, { "level": "ok", "title": "IPv4 diversity", "detail": "Two or more IPv4 addresses receive full points.", "category": "network", "max_points": 35, "earned_points": 35, "lost_points": 0 }, { "level": "ok", "title": "IPv6 connectivity", "detail": "AAAA availability.", "category": "network", "max_points": 35, "earned_points": 35, "lost_points": 0 }, { "level": "ok", "title": "DNS resolution", "detail": "At least one address family must resolve.", "category": "availability", "max_points": 40, "earned_points": 40, "lost_points": 0 }, { "level": "ok", "title": "HTTP response", "detail": "HTTP/2 200 ", "category": "availability", "max_points": 40, "earned_points": 40, "lost_points": 0 }, { "level": "ok", "title": "HTTPS final URL", "detail": "Final URL uses HTTPS.", "category": "availability", "max_points": 20, "earned_points": 20, "lost_points": 0 } ] }, "dns": { "records": { "A": [ "104.21.60.242", "172.67.202.199" ], "AAAA": [ "2606:4700:3031::ac43:cac7", "2606:4700:3033::6815:3cf2" ], "CNAME": [], "MX": [ "10 alt3.aspmx.l.google.com.", "5 alt2.aspmx.l.google.com.", "5 alt1.aspmx.l.google.com.", "1 aspmx.l.google.com.", "10 alt4.aspmx.l.google.com." ], "TXT": [ "\"facebook-domain-verification=1nxbhr4j5ymwjzyvgc4ooh9xgtuoq2\"", "\"google-site-verification=EY5vtIYb0glV5WLVQGZlNQyBnYMazrzjZTOR3N-_cDk\"", "\"google-site-verification=_K2C0Dg6zFbG0DdR0SeE6htTdG6fBjWt1uZbf7TRjME\"", "\"v=spf1 include:_spf.google.com include:sendgrid.net include:mailgun.org include:44406846.spf01.hubspotemail.net ~all\"", "\"google-site-verification=tapgR9xlkl7RTXyaC1GCiJEkr0pq3tdXZIr3ZwIMNBk\"", "\"google-site-verification=pl2vBEixkdxRL5hG7CqaIbF94T5l7WjLqe4-TZe4UPQ\"" ], "NS": [ "macy.ns.cloudflare.com.", "steven.ns.cloudflare.com." ], "SOA": [ "macy.ns.cloudflare.com. dns.cloudflare.com. 2410827511 10000 2400 604800 1800" ], "CAA": [], "DS": [], "DNSKEY": [], "RRSIG": [], "NSEC": [], "NSEC3": [], "SRV": [], "NAPTR": [], "TLSA": [], "SSHFP": [] }, "ipv4": [ "104.21.60.242", "172.67.202.199" ], "ipv6": [ "2606:4700:3031::ac43:cac7", "2606:4700:3033::6815:3cf2" ] }, "mail": { "spf": "v=spf1 include:_spf.google.com include:sendgrid.net include:mailgun.org include:44406846.spf01.hubspotemail.net ~all", "dmarc": "v=DMARC1; p=none; sp=none; rua=mailto:re+a1430af98900@inbound.dmarcdigests.com; pct=100", "dkim_selector": "google", "dkim_host": "google._domainkey.thebulwark.com", "dkim": "v=DKIM1; k=rsa; p=MIIBIjANBgkqhkiG9w0BAQEFAAOCAQ8AMIIBCgKCAQEAzhADvo48Q6UTtziQ7z5PBlXoIxpt5GjSjpxooOpfx08V31gEHKNhpT7wPBjRUnCedOUot6KKBF2/WBAHIuuP3hhJpaP03E/rhAciR5smzR4sGiglHNW79BwlqFFC0y9x1Ie4/3TgLDvU5+TkceI8Zh4LWo1nfcxzXYIsJRa4m7qmVRFNbNS8yIs8xh4hANbxF EGq93MiMTICQWNt+i3U37atuVXLFFfGWkclVdWnYXrBIDY9nPj5k3d4cckh3iuiBz8Wjg7n/j0hiInl1CHUR1OiiCMvJg8Xk3BjEYZA0YD64idUns/Welnrtu7FaeRZgNhnrbpdlz3/9FfyO9kVxwIDAQAB", "spf_analysis": { "valid": true, "lookups": 4, "final": "~all", "message": "Within the estimated limit" }, "dmarc_analysis": { "valid": true, "policy": "none" }, "bimi": "", "mta_sts": "", "tls_rpt": "" }, "advanced": { "ptr": "", "propagation": { "consistent": true, "results": [ { "provider": "Google", "server": "8.8.8.8", "result": [ "104.21.60.242", "172.67.202.199" ], "time_ms": 108.21 }, { "provider": "Cloudflare", "server": "1.1.1.1", "result": [ "104.21.60.242", "172.67.202.199" ], "time_ms": 47.02 }, { "provider": "Quad9", "server": "9.9.9.9", "result": [ "104.21.60.242", "172.67.202.199" ], "time_ms": 47.84 }, { "provider": "OpenDNS", "server": "208.67.222.222", "result": [ "104.21.60.242", "172.67.202.199" ], "time_ms": 43.95 }, { "provider": "AdGuard", "server": "94.140.14.14", "result": [ "104.21.60.242", "172.67.202.199" ], "time_ms": 90.06 } ] } }, "ssl": { "available": true, "issuer": "Google Trust Services", "subject": "thebulwark.com", "valid_from": "2026-06-27T08:44:21-05:00", "valid_to": "2026-09-25T09:43:03-05:00", "days_remaining": 45, "san": [ "thebulwark.com", "*.thebulwark.com" ], "protocol": "TLSv1.3", "cipher": "TLS_AES_256_GCM_SHA384" }, "http": { "url": "https://www.thebulwark.com/", "status": "HTTP/2 200 ", "http_version": "3", "headers": { "date": "Tue, 11 Aug 2026 02:20:26 GMT", "content-type": "text/html; charset=utf-8", "location": "https://www.thebulwark.com/", "report-to": "{\"group\":\"cf-nel\",\"max_age\":604800,\"endpoints\":[{\"url\":\"https://a.nel.cloudflare.com/report/v4?s=OcbyAxG7sMONcVY%2B9eGNOuYR%2Ff0FiA0zZtKYreaTqU4mVsbPRxLTbHGPyT1U9HzYwU2K%2FmI%2BK%2FnvfgkytlQg5vtCJMHE9p011IXbUe4Gpml3ZAkXSEId%2BR2pSTWFt2Y3zQ%3D%3D\"}]}", "nel": "{\"report_to\":\"cf-nel\",\"success_fraction\":0.0,\"max_age\":604800}", "server": "cloudflare", "cf-ray": "a293c2d8edf6efc8-STL", "alt-svc": "h3=\":443\"; ma=86400", "cf-cache-status": "HIT", "cache-control": "no-cache", "etag": "W/\"389f1-F3WTPbIP5Gc4O4mRTQhUQQYo3Uw\"", "link": "; rel=preconnect", "x-sub": "thebulwark", "strict-transport-security": "max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains; preload", "vary": "Accept-Encoding", "content-security-policy": "frame-ancestors 'self' https://*.substack.com https://substack.com", "x-cluster": "substack", "x-deploy": "2028be87d6", "x-powered-by": "Express", "x-served-by": "Substack", "x-service": "web", "set-cookie": "__cf_bm=IwfynOBwHpN9vj8shtIIuIMjJj6PEcDMLIJFmWGWvcY-1786414826.3809428-1.0.1.1-7KgdKMEd0JB92zlPF76gUDn3VaE3KbmcpcvZynw6RobkoVTS9v_P3.rvlgLGw6ZsVWHkvgjwjXQRKkAm4H_O.4ntd1uaHJ1vdf9e.whMFNCczHYz69ecV7uGJ9k6fAIi; HttpOnly; SameSite=None; Secure; Path=/; Domain=www.thebulwark.com; Expires=Tue, 11 Aug 2026 02:50:26 GMT" }, "security_checks": { "strict-transport-security": true, "content-security-policy": true, "x-content-type-options": false, "x-frame-options": false, "referrer-policy": false, "permissions-policy": false, "cross-origin-opener-policy": false, "cross-origin-embedder-policy": false, "cross-origin-resource-policy": false }, "server": "cloudflare", "powered_by": "Express" }, "webpage": { "url": "https://www.thebulwark.com/", "title": "The Bulwark | Substack", "description": "The Bulwark is home to Sarah Longwell, Tim Miller, Bill Kristol, JVL, Sam Stein, Catherine Rampell and more. We are the largest pro-democracy bundle on Substack for news and analysis on politics and culture—supported by a community built on good faith. Click to read The Bulwark, a Substack publication with millions of subscribers.", "success": true, "error": "", "status": 200 }, "network": { "104.21.60.242": { "success": false, "country": "", "region": "", "city": "", "asn": "", "organization": "", "isp": "" }, "172.67.202.199": { "success": false, "country": "", "region": "", "city": "", "asn": "", "organization": "", "isp": "" } }, "smtp": { "host": "alt3.aspmx.l.google.com", "ports": [ { "port": 25, "open": false, "time_ms": 1.1, "banner": "", "error": "Network is unreachable" }, { "port": 465, "open": false, "time_ms": 4022.6, "banner": "", "error": "Connection timed out" }, { "port": 587, "open": false, "time_ms": 4019.6, "banner": "", "error": "Connection timed out" } ] }, "visitor": { "ip": "216.73.217.62", "reverse": "", "country": "", "country_code": "", "region": "", "city": "", "latitude": null, "longitude": null, "isp": "", "organization": "", "asn": "", "timezone": "", "browser": "Other", "os": "Other", "language": "", "user_agent": "Mozilla/5.0 AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko; compatible; ClaudeBot/1.0; +claudebot@anthropic.com)", "is_bot": true, "cloudflare": false }, "analysis_time_ms": 116.25 }